- Traffic without conversions: unclear messaging and buying obstacles can cost you customers.
- Confusing navigation: customers may leave when information is difficult to find.
- Missing trust signals: limited proof, testimonials, or case studies can create hesitation.
- Poor performance and tracking: slow pages and unreliable data make problems harder to identify.
- Unclear next steps: weak calls to action and complicated buying processes can prevent conversions.
8 Signs Your Website Is Costing You Customers
Your website may be attracting the right visitors while making it difficult for them to take the next step. If your website isn't converting visitors into leads or sales, the problem may be how customers experience it.
Below are eight signs your website is costing you customers, and what to do about each one. Sometimes the warning signs are obvious, like a slow-loading page or a contact form that doesn't work.
Other times, they're harder to recognize: customers may struggle to understand what you offer or find the information they need to make a decision. For products that need explaining or configuring before purchase, small points of friction add up fast.
These issues can affect how customers perceive your business and whether they choose to buy. Recognizing the warning signs is the first step toward understanding where your website may be costing you customers.
1. Your Website Gets Traffic, but Few Visitors Convert
A website that attracts visitors but generates few sales may have problems with unclear messaging or friction in the buying process. If your website isn't generating leads despite steady traffic, it's worth investigating what happens after visitors arrive. They may be exploring your offerings without finding enough information to make a decision, or encountering obstacles that prevent them from taking action.
What to look for
- Website traffic is increasing, but inquiries or sales remain flat.
- High-traffic pages generate relatively few conversions.
- Visitors leave important landing pages without taking action.
- Traffic from certain marketing channels consistently underperforms.
What to do about it
- Start with a website conversion analysis that examines traffic and conversion performance together. Use Google Analytics to understand which channels and landing pages generate inquiries or purchases.
- Look beyond your overall conversion rate to evaluate page performance based on the actions visitors are expected to take.
Understanding where visitors lose momentum can help you identify what's preventing them from converting and where improvements could have the greatest impact.
See Your Website the Way Your Buyers Do
Answer five questions to see where visitors may be getting stuck on their way to a decision, and what to focus on first.
Start the Assessment
2. Your Website Messaging Doesn't Clearly Explain What You Offer
Unclear website messaging can make it difficult for customers to understand your products or services and how they solve their problems. When visitors can't quickly recognize the value of your offering, they may leave before exploring further.
If website copy relies heavily on industry terminology, internal processes, or broad claims about quality and expertise, customers may struggle to understand the relevance to their situation. Even well-designed websites can lose potential customers when their messaging doesn't make the value of the offering clear.
What to look for
- Your homepage describes your business without clearly explaining what customers gain.
- Product or service pages focus on features with little explanation of their practical value.
- Different pages communicate inconsistent messages.
- Customers frequently need additional explanations before understanding your offering.
What to do about it
Review your website content against the questions customers need answered before making a decision. A practical content audit should evaluate message clarity, relevance to customer needs, and whether each page provides a useful next step.
Run a content audit through the lens of the problems your customers are trying to solve:
- Does your homepage clearly explain what you offer?
- Do your product pages answer the questions customers have before making a decision?
- Can visitors understand the next step without contacting someone for clarification?
Use those findings to make your messaging clearer and more relevant to the questions customers have throughout the buying process.
3. You’re Making Website Decisions Without Reliable Data
Without reliable website analytics and conversion tracking, it's difficult to understand which marketing efforts generate leads or sales. Missing or inaccurate data can lead to wasted spending and make it harder to identify opportunities for improvement.
What to look for
- You track website traffic but have limited visibility into conversions.
- Analytics reports don't connect website activity to goals.
- Conversion tracking is inconsistent or doesn't reflect completed customer actions.
- Different teams use conflicting data to evaluate performance.
What to do about it
- Identify the actions that indicate meaningful progress toward a business goal.
- Depending on your website, these might include product selections, quote requests, account registrations, checkout steps, or completed purchases.
- Configure Google Analytics and Google Tag Manager to track those actions, then develop reporting that makes the results understandable and useful.
Reliable measurement connects website activity to business outcomes, giving your team a clearer picture of what's working and where improvements are needed.
From our experience: PontoonStuff
PontoonStuff had an established e-commerce business but limited visibility into which marketing efforts drove sales.
Nextpoint improved analytics and conversion tracking, then used the data to evaluate keyword performance and restructure Google Ads campaigns. We eliminated underperforming ad campaigns and redirected their budget toward higher-converting opportunities.
PontoonStuff now has reliable performance data to guide marketing investments and adjust its campaigns as demand changes.
4. Your Website Is Slow or Difficult to Use on Mobile
Slow website loading times or poor mobile usability can interrupt the customer experience and prevent visitors from completing important tasks. When pages take too long to load, or mobile layouts are difficult to navigate, even interested visitors might leave before taking action.
Even small frustrations can add up, creating unnecessary obstacles between your customers and their next step.
What to look for
- Pages load slowly, particularly on mobile devices.
- Navigation menus, buttons, or forms are difficult to use on smaller screens.
- Important content shifts unexpectedly or takes too long to appear.
- Mobile visitors convert at substantially lower rates than desktop visitors.
- Google PageSpeed Insights identifies performance or Core Web Vitals issues.
What to do about it
- Test your website across devices, focusing on the tasks your customers need to complete. Pay attention to how easily someone can find information or move through a more involved process.
- Use Google PageSpeed Insights to identify technical issues and review your analytics for differences in performance across devices.
Use these findings to prioritize improvements that make important tasks faster and easier for customers to complete.
5. Visitors Struggle to Find What They Need
Most visitors arrive at your website with a purpose. They might want to compare products, understand your services, find pricing information, or determine if your product or service can solve their problem.
Complicated navigation or poorly organized content makes customers work harder than necessary, and gives them a reason to leave.
For businesses with growing product catalogs or multiple sales channels, the challenge can extend beyond navigation on a single website. Customers may encounter products across different sites without a clear understanding of where to explore the full offering or how those experiences connect.
What to look for
- Visitors repeatedly move between pages without progressing.
- Important product or service information is buried within the website.
- Customers frequently reach out with questions your website could answer.
- User testing reveals confusion about where to find information.
What to do about it
- Evaluate your website navigation in whole from your customers' perspective.
- Consider what visitors need at each stage of their journey and if your website provides an intuitive path to that information.
- User interviews, usability testing, and behavioral analysis can reveal where people backtrack or become confused.
Understanding how customers search for products can reveal opportunities to improve navigation and content organization. A data-driven approach to website design makes those decisions based on actual customer behavior.
From our experience: DeckMate
DeckMate had an established customer base through multiple retail sites, but their growing catalog of marine components needed a dedicated online home.
Nextpoint began with an Online Presence Audit to understand how customers found and shopped for DeckMate products across different channels. Those findings guided the development of a dedicated brand destination, bringing the full catalog together under one brand while supporting its existing retail business.
The new site gave DeckMate a stronger brand presence and room to expand into additional e-commerce channels, while established retail traffic and sales remained steady.
See how Nextpoint helped DeckMate expand its online presence without disrupting existing sales
6. Your Website Doesn't Build Enough Trust
Before customers share their contact information or make a purchase, they need confidence in your business. Missing trust signals, like reviews, case studies, or clear company information can make potential customers hesitant to move forward.
Providing credible evidence and answering important questions helps customers evaluate your business with greater confidence. For those selling complex or premium products, customers may need additional reassurance before moving forward.
What to look for
- Your website makes claims without providing supporting evidence.
- Case studies, customer testimonials, or examples of past work are difficult to find.
- Product or service pages leave important questions unanswered.
- Contact information is difficult to find or missing.
- Processes or policies are inconsistent or missing.
What to do about it
- Identify the information customers need to feel confident choosing you (case studies, testimonials, product specifications, certifications, or process details).
- Make those details available where customers are evaluating their options.
- Review your content for gaps that may create uncertainty during the buying process.
Building trust starts with giving customers the information they need to make informed decisions and feel confident taking the next step.
7. Your Website Doesn't Have Clear Calls to Action
Unclear or missing calls to action can leave customers unsure of what to do. When the next step isn't obvious or relevant to their needs, interested visitors may leave without taking the next step.
Calls to action (CTAs) help customers understand how to move forward. Depending on the page, that might mean requesting a quote, exploring a product configurator, scheduling a consultation, or reviewing additional information.
Problems arise when CTAs are difficult to find or ask visitors to commit before they have enough information.
What to look for
- Important pages have no clear or relevant CTA.
- Multiple competing CTAs make it difficult to decide what to do.
- Buttons use generic language that doesn't explain what happens next.
- Visitors engage with content but rarely continue to the intended next step.
What to do about it
- Review your most important pages and identify the primary action each one should support.
- Make that action easy to find and clearly communicate what customers can expect after clicking.
- For visitors who aren't ready to convert, provide helpful secondary paths (related services, product comparisons, relevant blog posts, or case studies).
A strong UX design foundation uses thoughtful page structure and content hierarchy to help customers recognize their next step.
8. Customers Start the Buying Process but Don't Finish
A complicated buying process can prevent interested customers from completing a purchase. Few website problems are more frustrating than losing a customer who has already shown strong intent to buy.
Sometimes, customers are ready to commit, but the buying experience gets in the way. For businesses with configurable products or considered purchases, these challenges can become significant hurdles.
What to look for
- Visitors begin checkout or forms but rarely complete them.
- Customers repeatedly return to previous steps in a configuration process.
- Specific stages of the buying journey have unusually high abandonment rates.
- Customers contact your team for help completing tasks intended to be self-service.
What to do about it
Map the entire buying journey, from the first interaction through the completed purchase or inquiry.
- Identify where customers repeat steps or abandon the process. Funnel analysis, usability testing, and customer feedback can help reveal the reasons behind these behaviors.
- Use those findings to prioritize improvements that simplify decisions, reduce unnecessary steps, and give customers a clearer path toward completing their purchase.
A thoughtful design strategy helps uncover the reasons behind customer behavior, giving teams a clearer understanding of what needs to change.
From our experience: Caterpillar
Purchasing an industrial generator involves multiple decision-makers, each with different priorities. Caterpillar needed a clearer understanding of where buyers encountered friction and how to better connect them with its global dealer network.
Nextpoint interviewed buyers, specifiers, and dealers worldwide to map their journeys and identify opportunities for improvement. Those findings informed a buyer journey playbook and the design of a customer portal that connects project planning, specifications, and dealer collaboration.
The resulting portal design brings project planning and dealer collaboration into one connected experience, giving buyers a clearer path toward equipment configuration or rental.
See how Nextpoint helped Caterpillar map a clearer path to purchase
Where to Start Improving Your Website
Understanding where customers experience friction is the first step toward making meaningful improvements. From there, you can identify the underlying problems and decide where to focus your efforts.
We partner with teams to find where customers get stuck and turn those findings into practical improvements, through four focused offerings:
- Online Presence Audit: Evaluate your customer-facing digital experience to identify weaknesses and prioritize opportunities to improve usability, messaging, and conversions.
- Content Production Playbook: Assess your existing content, audience needs, and competitive landscape to identify gaps and guide future content development.
- Analytics & Measurement Setup: Improve conversion tracking, reporting, and measurement so your team can understand performance and make informed decisions.
- User Behavior Mapping: Examine customer journeys to identify where buyers get stuck and recommend improvements that make purchasing easier.
Together, these capabilities help businesses understand where they will be most effective in digital experience improvements and more accurately measure their impact.
Your website influences how customers discover your business and decide whether to take the next step. If you're seeing signs of friction, understanding where customers are getting stuck can help you identify what to improve first.
Find Out What's Holding Your Website Back
Take our 5-minute assessment to see where your website may be creating friction and what to look at first.
Start Your Assessment
